AdvertiseDonate
Friday, November 20, 2026Local news for Bergen County, New Jersey.
Bergen County Herald · 78 John Miller Way, Suite 326, Kearny, NJ 07032
News · Aurora

Susan Smith Denied Parole 32 Years After 1994 Killings

The South Carolina board voted unanimously to keep the 55-year-old in prison, with the next opportunity for release arriving in 2028.

By Pablo Serrano ·

Illustration for: Susan Smith Denied Parole 32 Years After 1994 Killings
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Susan Smith has spent more than three decades in South Carolina custody for the deaths of her two young sons, a case that drew global attention in the mid-1990s. On Thursday, the state parole board voted unanimously to deny her request for release.

Smith, who is now 55, received a life sentence in 1995 after a jury convicted her of drowning her sons, Michael, age 3, and Alex, age 14 months, at John D. Long Lake. Under the state laws in effect at her sentencing, she became eligible for parole consideration after 30 years. The board had previously rejected her application in 2024, and the agency’s statutes allow her to petition again every two years if denied.

David Smith, the boys’ father, appeared at the hearing to oppose his ex-wife’s release. He pinned a photograph of his sons over his heart, a gesture he has maintained since their 1995 trial. David Smith told the board that 32 years feels like yesterday and that he is speaking on behalf of children who cannot speak for themselves. He characterized the killings as deliberate acts rather than accidents.

Smith participated in the virtual hearing by video call from prison. She required a two-thirds vote from the seven-member board to be released. During her testimony, Smith expressed deep remorse for taking the lives of her innocent children and stated that she is not the same person she was 32 years ago. She asked the board for a chance to do good in the world, though she did not cry during this specific session.

The likelihood of release remained low due to the board’s historical statistics, which show a grant rate of only 4 percent. Most approved cases involve non-violent offenses. Prosecutor Tommy Pope argued that Smith killed her sons out of selfishness after a romantic relationship ended. He noted that Smith had enjoyed the media attention during her nine-day cover story and continued to seek relationships behind bars.

Defense attorneys and psychologist Jessie Hill presented evidence that Smith’s mental health has stabilized due to medication and life changes, including menopause. They argued she poses a low risk of reoffending and has no other criminal history. The case has remained notable for Smith’s initial nine-day claim that a Black carjacker kidnapped her sons, a narrative that prosecutors and public figures have long linked to racial tropes of the era.

Investigators previously established that Smith’s Mazda sank in approximately six minutes. Surveillance footage showed water rising through the vehicle's vents, and the boys were found upside down in their car seats, with one hand pressed against the window. Smith is eligible to request parole again in 2028.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Bergen County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Bergen County, New Jersey. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Bergen County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Bergen County, New Jersey. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.